top of page
Search

The Incredible Potential for Failure in Canada's AI Strategy

Writer: Lillian Taylor
Lillian Taylor
2 days ago
5 min read


Canadian telecom giant Telus has recently released its plans for three BC data centers to fuel a Canadian AI push. Already granted federal and provincial support, the project has been fast-tracked and two of the centers will be operational later this year . This decision has been met with public backlash, through protests and statements from people like BC Green party leader Emily Lowan. Supporters cite the importance for Canadian data to be stored on Canadian soil, and that Canadians can and should be a leader in AI and technological development (Little, 2026). 


Look, I agree that digital sovereignty is important. Discussion surrounding it has been on the rise in the Canadian sphere. The tariff and trade wars with the US and the push to “buy Canadian” has highlighted the fact that digitally, Canadians are largely dependent on US regulation and laws. Data is in the hands of these American companies, and with the questionable efficacy of Canadian misinformation laws on social media, the path forward on regulating them is murky. The Telus data centers are a corporate response to improve digital sovereignty, but the federal government have responded with its "AI for All" policy. While generally a Canadian policy aiming to promote digital development is definitely needed, it must be carefully considered- including environmental impacts. The federal government promises a lot within their policy, but whether it is what Canada needs, or serving who it alleges is still in question.


All digital services have some environmental impact- “cloud storage” is somewhere, physically, taking up space in a data center, made with progressively harder to find minerals, and powered by electricity. Generative AI specifically, with its hastily built data centers, all needing to be outfitted with cutting-edge computer hardware and often drawing from or affecting municipal water or electricity supply, is one of the most obvious examples of the environmental damage from technology and digital infrastructure. As a result, the "AI for All" policy, and all other AI related government policies must be heavily scrutinized, given the potential for environmental harm.

Despite multiple mentions in the government of Canada's analysis of their 30 day public consultation of respondents concerns for the environmental impact (Government of Canada, 2026a), there is little mention of those concerns in their actual strategy. There is a vague promise of leading a "sustainable data centre push" via Canada's renewable energy grid(Government of Canada, 2026c). This view of the environmental impact is too narrow. It fails to consider sound pollution, light pollution, and that in a time of rising natural disasters from climate change, the reliability of infrastructure like water sources and electricity will decrease. The true environmental impact from AI is way larger and more complex, as seen in American communities living nearby data centers.


In America, people face rising water and electricity bills from nearby data centers increasing demand and straining available resources (Greenfield, 2026). While the proposed Telus data centers in Vancouver are allegedly not going to increase BC Hydro Bills, they will put some strain on the system- which reports needing 9,700 gigawatt hours of additional electricity each year by 2035 to power BC- and use enough energy to heat approximately 85,000 homes in BC (Phan Nay, 2026). Safeguards are reportedly in place to keep electricity reliable and affordable, but we are also living in a time of decreasing reliability and affordability (Phan Nay, 2026). BC Hydro can promise capping the amount of electricity these data centers use, but there needs to be transparent measurements released to the public on the amount they end up drawing, to guarantee these data centers do not create added strain. I do not think that "trust me bro" is enough for me to trust them, bro on an issue with so much risk. If these companies do not deliver on these promises, and our governments do not hold them to account, Vancouverites lives will get worse.

Overall, the governments "AI for All" policy and the development of Telus data centers highlight the fact that we are rushing into AI development with little concrete regulation. These Telus data centers have been fast-tracked, with two opening in 2026 and the third 2029, and the only pieces of policy regulating(and regulating is doing a lot of heavy lifting) them are the BC governments competitive bid process- which allegedly favours data centers utilizing heat recovery, water-use and other energy efficiencies (Vanderdeen, 2026), the federal governments "Enabling large-scale sovereign AI data centres" initiative, which promotes the inclusion of similar priorities as the BC government (Government of Canada, 2026b), and the previously mentioned "AI for All" strategy. While there are monetary incentives within these to encourage certain data center building practices, there is nothing concretely regulating data centers. Governments can promise to prioritize data centers which similarly say they use environmentally conscious practices and have Indigenous participation, but there is nothing truly forcing them to. And in our current, environmentally dire reality, I think we should expect concrete regulations around data centers before we begin approving and building these projects.


Telus has outlined some environmental impact mitigation measures it says the new data centers will use, like a closed-loop cooling system that can absorb heat without letting water evaporate, and planning to use some recycled water from BC Place (Phan Nay, 2026). However, there are no specifics for sound pollution. Constant humming is a reality for those in America living near data centers (Yañez-Barnuevo, 2026). While Telus has promised to reduce certain environmental impacts, these data centers will still realistically negatively affect the environment and British Colombians living nearby. 


The current government response is to essentially leave the choice of environmentally conscious data centers (whether or not that is even something that really exists) up to the companies. This leaves significant room for greenwashing, as there are no actual standards on what a sustainable data center should look like. Rather, companies can easily spin certain practices to make them appear more environmentally conscious than they are.

It is not unthinkable for the federal government to have set out stronger environmental expectations in AI for All- they were able to be more specific when it came to privacy concerns. While it is not the strongest- as AI for All isn't a law- they specifically promoted open-source AI and modern day privacy and safety laws around AI(Government of Canada, 2026c). This shows that the government could have actually mentioned expectations around sustainable data centers, rather than vague references- especially considering how it was routinely mentioned in their public consultation. The lack of doing so is a warning indicator- despite their words, they do not often match in action.


If governments need recommendations on development of AI policy- which they likely got in the public consultation from experts- concrete regulations for data centers would look like restricting the water wastage and electricity usage nationally (the latter is already done in BC), conducting mandatory comprehensive impact studies for proposed areas, measuring and restricting noise pollution, and mandating certain less environmentally detrimental technology be used in construction and operations. If they are serious about Canada leading AI development, they should invest in research to reduce e-waste, and mandate transparency towards data centers use of electricity, water, and production of waste. Failure to comply with Canadian regulations should be met with fines adjusted to company profit, and restriction of operations.

Unfortunately, economic benefits have been winning out over our environment. People are protesting the development of the Telus data centers in Vancouver, and more environmentally aware politicians are calling for a moratorium on AI data center development until more concrete regulations are in place (Little, 2026). It is important to show governments and companies that these decisions are unpopular, and use what power we have in our system to force them to back down, or slow this development. It was done- somewhat- in Ontario, with Billy Bishop airport expansion, it is possible here too.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page